A Tale of Two Re-Reprints

How do you keep interest alive in decades-old comics properties in a market that is already awash in contemporary graphic novels and Manga? Sure, to greying aficionados like many of us, the great EC artists and Chester “Dick Tracy” Gould were seminal to a comic art form that remains the fastest growing sector of the books business. But who is going to tell the kids? Two publishers recently reissued previously published classic comics reprints volumes in new formats, which follow radically different approaches. Dark Horse picked up an EC Comics restoration project begun in 2006 by Gemstone to reprint much of that famed pre-Code library. Tales from the Crypt, which initially comprised five hardback volumes, is now available as a single omnibus-style cinder block of a tome: 1027 pages at $150. Meanwhile, Clover Press, which now publishes most of the Library of American Comics books, has taken a very different tack in paring select LOAC Dick Tracy reprints into smaller, more affordable paperbacks. One publisher decided to make its reprint handier and cheaper, while the other made theirs more unwieldy and costly.

The Complete Tales from the Crypt pretty much recompiles those earlier five volumes. So far as I can tell from comparing the two versions, the page dimensions, digital recoloring, semi-gloss paper, etc. are identical. Much of the prefatory material by Russ Cochran, Joe Dante and others also appeared in the earlier editions. Owners of the previously published five-volume set likely will want to pass on this one, unless they have a special taste for excessive girth and weight. Moreover, Dark Horse’s paperback versions of TFTC at $20 each, are a cheaper, lighter way to go for the exact same content.

Many ECphiles take exception with this series’ digital recoloring. Unlike some reprint projects, this one doesn’t aspire to recreate the look and feel of old timey comics reading. Their pure, even blocks of color, high contrast, and semi-gloss paper are far removed from, say, TASCHEN’s devotion in its EC and Marvel reprints to preserving the Ben-Day dots and pulpy texture of old comics. While the publisher claims to be following famed EC colorist Marie Severin’s lead, the Dark Horse product often feels amped, even garish. I am not as put off by their approach as some critics. The underlying line art remains crisp and visible, even if the colors feel too vibrant for the often ghoulish material. Purists will likely prefer the black and white EC reprints from Fantagraphics. Still, Dark Horse is publishing in hardcover, paperback and now omnibus formats the only affordable version of the library in full color.

Clover Press’s refiguring of LOAC’s long-running collection of Chester Gould’s complete run on Dick Tracy goes in the opposite direction of Dark Horse. The original hardcovers typically contained two years of dailies and Sundays in each volume. This new paperback version, The Chester Gould Dick Tracy Collection dips selectively into that full history to include single years. The softcovers preserve the dimensions of the hardbacks but come in a die-cut slipcase illustrated by contemporary comic artists. The latest two volumes are for 1961 and 1962, with ’63 and ’64 coming soon.

The first four reissues earlier this year highlighted the early 1940s when some of Gould’s most famous villains (Mole, Flattop, The Brow) appeared and the strip was at its violent, gruesome peak. The 1961-64 span sees Gould at his most spacy (literally). Among his weirdest villain creations, The Brush, sports a mask with loose bristles. Tracy is also bedeviled by some rogue chimps, and then goes into space. Eventually, he ventures to the Moon, where sidekick Junior falls in love with and marries the alien Moon Maid. In his own weird, buttoned down, famously reactionary way, Chester Gould was getting trippy.

In choosing this period of Dick Tracy, Clover also addresses a market need. The hardcover volumes covering the early 60’s currently demand some insane prices among resellers, so more affordable versions of these years in particular are most welcome. And wrapping these $30 paperbacks in Tracy imagery from contemporary artists like Brent Schoonover and Cat Staggs is at least an attempt to connect this century-old icon to new audiences. The books are eminently handy, but in order to make them so, Clover has dropped the extensive background essays from the hardbacks. Nevertheless, this LOAC series continues to  include the crispest versions of Gould’s art I have seen.

In different ways, both of these Dark Horse and Clover re-reprints follow that same important goal:  making classic comic art more relevant to a generation that has been raised on graphic narratives and Manga but not aware of the legacy that informed them. It is an important project we can only celebrate.


Discover more from Panels & Prose

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply